Showing posts with label Teaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teaching. Show all posts

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Progress and Becoming...

I'm wrapping up this semester (and yes, posting on the blog is one of the ways I procrastinate) and thinking about this school year. One of the beautiful (and terrifying) things about my program is that we have to write an exam after our second year that "theorizes our learning." It's my opportunity to take my life experiences and my scholarly experiences and synthesize them to produce the thing I'll be spending the next three years of my life on. It's an invented genre of writing, so I spend a fair amount of time thinking to myself, "what in the world does this look like? Where do I begin?" But amidst all of that questioning is a genuine excitement about this paper that is growing stronger and stronger as the semester draws to a close.

I had my annual meeting with my program's co-chairs a couple of weeks ago, and the Hawk said some really great things about how she's seen me progress from situating myself as a teacher to situating myself as a scholar this year and how important that transition is. I actually connected this moment to a spiritual truth I'm beginning to understand, but I'll get around to explaining that later. I've begun to notice a change in my academic life too. When I realized that I was interested in language ideology and the classroom, I called my dad, who listened to me babble and then said, "But that will make you a linguist, right?" Uh oh. I came here with zero background in linguistics. Zero. As the Hawk said, my interests were ahead of my coursework (and I appreciated the oh-so-positive spin on "you're not prepared for this" she offered), so I've spent most of this year trying to catch up. And catch up I have. This week, I asked a question in class that the prof connected back to a theory of language we haven't addressed this semester. But I actually understood his answer and was able to engage in a scholarly conversation that extended the class discussion. I think I'm getting there. My first exam is still not approved, but once I finish writing the thousands of papers I have due in the next week (oh, come on, just because I don't teach literature anymore doesn't mean I can't use hyperbole!), I'm submitting a new draft. This is going to happen. If I can't write a paper that makes them happy, I'll outlast them. At some point, they'll give in and approve it. That's right. I'm using sheer tenacity to progress through a PhD program. Hard-headedness has to be good for something, right?

I spent this year researching for the Eagle instead of teaching, and I have really mixed feelings about it. I miss teaching. A lot. Even on my bad teaching days I know that it's a place where I'm capable and competent, and I don't feel that way about most of my work! I miss seeing my students understand and feeling like I'm able to have a positive impact on their experiences. I started tutoring high school students to fill the gap, which has given me great joy. They are wonderful kids. They're high achievers, and I really enjoy finding ways to show them how much fun English can be. I'm such a word nerd. It's all the best aspects of teaching, without the paperwork and bureaucracy. The research, though, has been a good experience for me, because now I've seen firsthand how this process works and I'm able to enter into conversations without sounding like a complete idiot. I don't feel like I offer as much to the planning and execution as my research partner C, but her interests are firmly seated in what we're doing and mine aren't, really.

I'm planning a "year in review" writing day sometime in the near future. I used to do that when I was teaching, and it's a really nice way to honestly examine the choices I'm making and how those choices are working for me--professionally and personally. I think I'll post it here, because I don't mind the transparency. It's a good thing.

Thursday, February 24, 2011

The Thrill of Victory...

and the agony of defeat. This has been my past two weeks. Actually, it's been my month, come to think of it. First of all, I'm apparently bad at this game. I've been wanting to post--it really helps me process and reflect--but somehow I just haven't made time for it. I'll be perfectly honest. This may not be the best time for me to post a blog. I don't want this blog to become a negative space, but it is really important that it be an honest, authentic space. That's the whole point of it being "anonymous." Of course, the only people I know of who read this know perfectly well who I am, but I'm good with them knowing what's going on.

Let me be perfectly clear. I love what I'm doing. I'm surrounded by incredibly smart people who also happen to be wonderfully kind. I spent most of last year desperately wanting to be challenged. I know being challenged is painful--growing hurts, but it's also really good for me. The past two weeks have been a time of real growth. I discovered what it is I'm really intellectually interested in, which was such a wonderful moment for me. I've been wandering aimlessly through the halls of academia, and now my wandering has a purpose! It's so exciting, and I'm beginning to explore some questions that I'm passionately invested in understanding. I had a wonderful conversation with one of my advisors, and she encouraged my interests and got excited along with me. That was a fabulous day! The Bible says, "where there is no vision, the people perish." Never has that been more clear to me. I'm just starting to formulate my questions about language ideologies, but those questions are already prompting me and shaping my writing and thoughts. I'll write more about these interests soon. Right now, I'm more concerned with what happened today.

I submitted a paper proposal for one of my professors a couple of weeks ago. She asked me to redo it and resubmit. The first proposal wasn't good. I fully recognize that. The class doesn't really completely align with my research interests, though it is something I really should be reading, thinking, and writing about. However, my general lack of interest in this field has made it particularly difficult to write a proposal. I busted my behind Tuesday to get a new proposal for her, and I was pretty excited about this one. I felt like it managed to combine my burgeoning interests in language ideologies with the purpose of the class. This afternoon, she pulled me aside and asked me to redo the proposal. Again. I see her point. My questions were too broad and they weren't really clearly formed. However, we aren't even halfway through the semester. I still need to research things in order to make them more clearly articulated. I know this. It isn't the professor's fault. But I cried anyway. My only saving grace is that I managed to suck it up in the hour and a half remaining in class and didn't cry in front of her. I waited until my wonderful friends and program-mates took me for a drink and I. lost. it. I think the waiter thought I was post-breakup. Little did he know I was only post-feedback.

I keep thinking that at the crux of my intellectual/identity struggle this semester has been that I don't know what valuable things I'm contributing to the community. I certainly know I am capable of contributing such things. But it would be incredibly helpful to have a hint as to what they are from the authority figure in the classroom. This is part of the process. I understand that. But it doesn't make it suck any less. My "takeaway" from this? The words of a teacher are incredibly powerful--no matter what level the student is at and how intelligent or capable that student may be. I need to embrace the power I have in my classroom and use it to build my students up. I need to be intuitive about what kind of feedback my students need and give it to them--both the good and the "bad."

I've been lifting weights with one of my friends, and this feels a little like that. I don't like going, but I enjoy how I feel afterwards. I like the way my sore muscles feel. I don't like the way I feel right now, but I know I'll enjoy how it feels later. I'm holding out for that, at least.

Friday, November 12, 2010

Gah.

I have this student. I'll call him Dean. He's a smart kid--witty and engaging. He contributes to class discussions, sometimes with an off-the-wall comment, but always something that turns out to be productive. But I just can't reach him. He's not a good writer, and I'm not entirely sure he's ready for this university, but I've reached more difficult cases before. I've had kids who didn't have his intelligence or personality become successful writers. Last week, I really thought I was making progress. He has turned in several assignments late, and wasn't going to get credit for one of them. I asked him to stay after class, but he left early. So I decided to email him. Four drafts later, I sent the email. He should be glad he didn't see that first draft! It was a little harsh. Heck, the fourth draft was still, shall we say, direct. He just isn't going to pass unless he pulls himself together. He stayed after class the next day and we had a chat. It went really well! He seemed to understand the stakes and why I wasn't pleased with his work so far. I also communicated to him how much I appreciated his contribution to our class. All in all, it was a very positive meeting. He assured me that he was going to make more of an effort, and like a rank amateur, I believed him.

The next week, he turned a final draft in that can only be described as gibberish. I'm not even sure what he was writing about, nor am I sure what assignment he was responding to. It certainly wasn't the one I wrote! It was so off-base that I couldn't even grade it (I've never had this problem before...not even when my high school seniors thought "Hank the Cow Dog" was fine literature). I wrote a note at the top, asking him to revise and resubmit for grading. I'm really upset. He's the kind of kid that isn't motivated by low grades or pep talks, and by the time I figured that out, it was halfway through the semester and he was already not doing well. I was really hoping that this was the paper where I could give him a somewhat higher grade, which might motivate him a little to finish out the semester strong.

He didn't show up to class today.

You know, I thought that teaching college would put some distance between me, my students, and their failures, but it hasn't. I still take it so personally. I teach. They learn. If I teach and they don't learn, was that teaching? Dean is the kind of kid who needs the opportunity education can provide him, and I desperately want him to take advantage of it. I'm without the "troops" I used to deploy as a middle/high school teacher--coaches, parents, principals...I feel like I've thrown him lifeline after lifeline and he'd just rather drown because grabbing hold is just too much effort. I hate it when one of my students chooses to fail. It makes me feel like I've failed.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Finding Myself in the 4th Circle...

It's standardized testing season here in the South. Yay. That's right. Just 26 eighth graders and I (myself? My brain hurts too much for good grammar) in a stuffy room that smells like a skunk crawled up in it and died--for three hours. I decided sometime during the second day of testing that the Rapture could occur and I would never know. Why? Well, for two reasons. First, everyone in the building could leave and I would be oblivious. There's something so unnatural about a silent middle school, and there is literally no one in the halls except the principal and the guidance counselors. I believe there are some hall monitors stationed at strategic locations, but I never see them from my classroom. Once I close my door and the announcement comes on to start the test, it's as silent as the grave. No kids in the hall, no loudspeaker announcements, no one coming to the door wanting something...it's a little freaky. Then I started to think that I might miss the sounding of the celestial trumpet because I was in the 4th circle of hell. Seriously. Have you ever paced a room constantly monitoring students for three straight hours? No sitting. No reading. No grading. Just monitoring. Sometime during the first hour, I felt my IQ begin to drop. I just can't handle the monotony. Honestly, I would really rather take the test myself. At least it would keep my mind occupied...but we're not even allowed to see the test questions, so I can't even read over their shoulders! It's just not worth my teaching certificate to read the questions--I plan on keeping that even if I'm not going to be using it next year! Then I started to wonder who exactly dwells in Dante's 4th circle of hell and decided that I don't spend enough reading quality material if I don't remember that. I could look it up, but I currently lack the motivation.

I'll admit to feeling a little odd about the whole testing situation. It's my last year in public education, most likely, and I've come to realize that, around here, the testing serves no real purpose. It is my professional opinion that the standardized test data should inform instruction, instead of just giving an arbitrary score. The way we test, value added analysis (where we can track a single student's progress from year to year) is mathematically impossible. I think that's one of the most valuable pieces of information a standardized test can give because it allows the teacher to see how the students progress in the course of a year. You still have other factors at play, but it can show some trends in student performance. The other thing I don't get from our state department is an accounting of how my students do by standard. I would be very interested to see which standards my students as a whole aren't on target for, because then I could adjust my instruction to cover these elements more thoroughly. Of course, I don't believe in teaching to a test, but I do see that teachers AND STUDENTS need to be held accountable for a year's learning. The only efficient way I can see to do this is to test everyone. I'm okay with that. What I'm not okay with is comparing last year's 8th grade scores to this year's 8th grade scores. That's like comparing apples to oranges. I'm also not okay with the great mystery behind our test. I get why teachers can't read the test. Sadly, not everyone is ethical. But why can't teachers be allowed to sit for a sample test in all the subject areas they teach? If the kids know what they should know, and I teach what I should teach, why the smoke and mirrors???

That's my rant. I'm done now--and so is standardized testing! I do think it's interesting how my mindset is beginning to shift from seeing just how my individual classroom works to how education in general works--and what doesn't work--and what I can do to enact some positive change. As I start this Ph.D., that's going to be something I need to constantly keep in front of me. Tomorrow is Friday, and we're moving into the end of the school year. I'm a little sad, especially when my babies have adult-like conversations with me about their future, or mine. I love it when they have adult-like conversations. It makes me feel like I've done something positive in their lives when they come to me to talk and share something of themselves.